In a word, discoverability is why they can’t have the same rule. And until I went to grab these screenshots, I hadn’t used the Strava desktop app this entire week. Communication can be somewhat difficult like the time they sent me an email saying that my charge would be $2.99 on 9/4/20, but it ended up being $7.99…. Over the last few days, that original tweet from a month ago went viral, and as a result, Strava took immediate action to toggle this feature to ‘No One’ for the entire Strava platform. The more I think about it the worse it gets. This is essentially the same as removing the feature. I got a response to the ticket I submitted to Strava before seeing this article. In any case, I think the bigger issue is Strava not simply defining these automatically. Segments gone unless you pay, Flyby and Run With gone completely. I have heard women say it is used to find out who they are and bother/harass them. Again, if you press the ‘regenerate’ button on Strava’s Privacy zones, you’ll notice it doesn’t actually center on your house (and it hasn’t for years). Then hit up Wiggle at the link below! . . So do the recent changes pushing more people to become paying members, reduces the total number of people using Strava. Now, I’ve had more than enough of their crap. I cover all the units to buy (and avoid) for the 2020-2021 indoor training season. Install $ pip install strava-flyby. I’d like to make some friends who run in my area, but not with random guys on the Internet, and the fact that they live near me and run the same routes isn’t really that comforting. Pretty much cut and dry, no apologize for any inconvenience. Just because I run/cycle, and you run/cycle, doesn’t mean we have anything in common. But it’s the way it was for five years, and in that five years, many people became very used to it. Get them nagging for a subscription all the time. He (Mark) got here the same way I did. Most people won’t bother going into settings to turn it on. It seems pretty daft to me not to do that. As nations we need to protect the weak among us. Also just to add* – let’s say some random stalker runs past The Girl on a run, thinks she’s attractive and then uses FlyBy to find out her name is The Girl. I checked my settings and it was still set as everyone. I read it over a morning cuppa just after 6am and it spurred me on to have another look at my privacy settings. That’s a pretty closed-minded view. Or, applying a filter for any activities to hide a randomly changing portion of the first part of the activity (such as 200-400m worth). I would still want to have to be able to see friends see flyby by default. Plus, I’d argue if a person is that determined to sit by their computer for years waiting for privacy zones to update to triangulate the exact spot of someone within that few hundred meter radius, it would seem a heck of a lot better option to simply just go sit outside the routes they ran/biked and see where they ended up. It should be there for you albeit empty. This is a monumental error by Strava. When I’m doing a long solo mountain run and only see one or two other runners, it makes for a nice connection to be able to see what other crazy sole was out there. If I passed someone and we chatted for a minute, there’s little chance we’d stop to exchange details. When I click on the link for flyby it now gives me a world map instead of my ride. This issue should now be resolved with the latest version of the Strava app, v181.0.3. I enabled; No problem, the product comparison data is constantly updated with new products and new features added to old products! I’ll sometimes delete these older vacation zones down the road after I’ve left, if it’s a spot I’m not going back to. When a profile isn’t public, you can’t see a list of activities on the profile page, but you can still find and view the athlete’s public activities if they’re shown in segments, grouped activities, or flyby’s. I only got the link back after changing the visiblity of the activity to everyone. I was expecting it be turned off moving forward but i have lost all of it unless I guess people go and turn it back on manually which I think most people won’t or won’t care to do. But more practically, this allows me to decide when and where I share my location. Check out ….Yeah you can turn it back on, but almost no one will know about that so flyby is effectively dead. In regards to the issue of not communicating the change, I wish they had done it instead of me learning about it in an article days after. Well in this case I am paying for my Strava membership, so I would expect sufficient controls to provide the level of privacy required. Also if I click flyby it opens a new tab but just loads a map of the world and then stops, no ride details load. Start times are only visible to your followers, so what’s the problem really? It’s illegal in the EU for very good reason, and GDPR has been debated by world experts in privacy to ensure the right balance between making data available and keeping people safe and most importantly so that joe public doesn’t have to become an expert to stay safe. I aim to leave no stone unturned. Which was quite often a bummer but now the feature is really useless. Tbh Strava is becoming more and more irrelevant. Why aren't my activities counting towards a Club leaderboard? This would have been in the early stages of the pandemic when many people wanted to deeply debate mask usage. One second they remove features, the next they add them back. I’ve re-viewed some of them and as expected I’m the only one in them (when previously there were many). It seemed to appeal to new runners who are just so darn excited about their new hobby and want to tell everyone about it. To get there you have to bring up the drop down box on the top right of the page (lap top) and select “Settings”. I didn’t get the link to see flyby’s back either after I enabled flyby again. Add friends to this ride (Orange Button) ... you will still be able to upload activities although health data will be removed and some features may not work. Totally legit, and something people should be aware of. nuke it immediately. I just submitted a ticket to Strava last night showing that somehow the switch to No One under Flyby privacy was made without my knowledge. But, thou shall not let factual accuracy get in the way of viral internet furor over something that’s been around half a decade. Then, I come here and write about my adventures. I have tried to use meet-up but with very poor results; 2 out of 3 were able to join but the other could not. To prevent Strava Flyby from sharing your information with other users, please follow these steps: ... by enhancing their privacy and security and not working … How to Change your Default Highlight Image. D) I leave Group Activities enabled: I’m good with this, and it’s fun to see who I’m riding/running with when looking back. Just recently was riding with a work colleague and that fact was indicated on the activity summary (“with …“). Want to compare the features of each product, down to the nitty-gritty? Anyway, I decided to cancel after paying this wonderful service for 3 years. I am sure someone else will just redo them in the future. After that I used flyby to see every person that went past the virtual me, was very useful. It is nice to know the history of it, but I am sad it disappeared. This is all gone. Without them consenting and sometimes without them knowing. Strava. My bad, lesson learned. This excitability seems to be an attribute of new, enthusiastic individuals who just discovered exercise and want to share it with the world. NOTE: I am currently extremely busy with work. Here’s my most recent gadget recommendations guide and trainers here – covering almost every category of sports gadgets out there. “Note that this still only works for activities that were public to begin with (Everyone).”. On the left side of the feature it showed which people were legit close, and which people were further away. I’m the same as you Ray, I make everything Private by default an change it, which is another bug bear, the location of the Private setting in the App is poor, right above the Delete Activity button, the number of times I’ve hit delete by mistake !!! Privacy zones are a radius around a point that won’t be shown in activities. Strava is one of the most ubiquitous cycling applications. Actually, privacy zones haven’t been perfect radius around a point for a while. Flybys Replay View the Race Replay on Strava Flybys: Sally Gap Replay. Very disappointing … they could have made everyone’s default “anonymous” by not showing their name or their avatars . Equally there might even have been romances that started with a Strava flyby. I agree – no information at all is counter-productive. While a ride may be “public”, it is relatively difficult to identify a random person you see on a ride without Flyby. Asking someone their name requires their knowledge and consent, Strava previously set this up such that neither was needed from the athlete in question. In my case, I virtually always start my rides/runs a block or three away. However, that case actually has nothing to do with Strava Flyby. Heads should roll. I always take a look at the flybys and I noticed it gone yesterday. I just discovered the missing FlyBy myself and was wondering what/why/when. Answer, none! Period. ” So activities marked private were/are never visible (despite the Twitter user’s statement to the contrary).”. We know the basic idea is sound and popular it just needs better management. Strava really know how to p*** off their users. I rarely ever even record that, but I’m certainly not going to show my kids’ school locations on Strava. We now have the GDPR, and companies – at least any that operate within arms reach of an EU state – have to be _very_ diligent about protecting privacy, or risk very large fines. Strava quickly disabled the 5+ year old feature, but hasn’t really communicated that well in any way. I think this was the biggest privacy issue with flyby, that you could see where and athletes on your flyby list started and finished their activities. I’ve never paid for subscription and, after this, never will. Hey presto! This was by far my favorite Strava feature; if I’d known I wouldn’t have renewed for another year… Strava really has the most crap customer service and public engagement. Knowing that “Ray Maker” runs every day near Schipol narrows the search enough that you’ll almost certainly only find one person matching that search. nobody forces you to put the center of the privacy zone over your house! I set all my activities to private and adjust them based on what I am doing and if I want to share. They definitely should have and still be making a lot of noise about it, maybe even nagging everyone that it’s on, with an easy option to turn it off, rather than just assuming 100% of their users wanted it off. I use it when I need it. Attribute Explanation; Flyby : A ( ) means that this activity was a flyby with the primary activity. 0. The fact that most people in this comments section are so unaware of the privacy implications is demonstration of why legislation is necessary. Usage. I don’t know about “dead”, but I think they are treading water looking for an exit strategy. Resolved: Year in Sport not loading for some athletes on iOS . When this setting is turned off, no one will be able to see your activities by using this feature. But that initial tweet assertion isn’t even true either – as that other user may have had a privacy zone set, so the end-point of that workout as seen by a potential stalker isn’t actually the end point – it just picks a semi-random point on the route near the privacy zone edge and calls it done. Click above for all the details. I think you’ve seen the difference between non-public profiles and non-public activities. GOES 0.0.2 Mar 24, 2020 Download and process data from GOES-16 and GOES-17. It is annoying, it was an amazing feature for looking at both running and cycling races after the event and comparing your pacing to that of others. I wish I didn’t have to worry about the constant changes that get in my way. So IMO the clock is now ticking for FlyBys. Get all your awesome high quality DCR kit and gear here! The FlyBy feature is basically dead now. 1 turn it off I’m certainly not renewing and am about to explore the possibility of a cancellation and refund. This is a quite complicated way to achieve this, when you could just create a segment there… same effect, and even nice statistics , You will be able to see that you rode with them, but it won’t show on theirs that they rode with you. – If you stop within or pass through a privacy zone during the middle of an activity, this portion will not be hidden. Had a local case in DC where a cyclist assaulted some walkers who were posting BLM posters/flyers. At least he wasn’t the guy in charge of security at Equifax I guess. You could say strava is in sleep mode. Why let them waste more VC? To share your activities on Flyby, change your Flyby privacy controls to “Everyone.” This is a really good compromise! I would much rather just scroll through ads and get the segments back for free. At least, if you believe Strava Segments are the soul of what makes Strava, well, Strava. https://www.dcrainmaker.com/images/2020/10/StravaFlyby.mp4, ‘Soldiers publish secret location data on social network and are surprised it’s public’. I had no idea they turned it off. I wonder if Strava is not realizing what your Fenix6 is yet… An easy test is to look at the elevation plot on an out an back activity – if using Strava’s elevation model it will be Perfectly symmetrical, if using the Fenix6 barometer it will be close but have deviations and/or drift. Wasn’t illegal back then. Zwift ride ons are the only feedback from strangers that doesn’t send me to privacy settings to see what went wrong. I didn’t noticed that until reading your article… probably my strava browser plugin blocking all advertisement from feed lol. ... Flyby is a Strava Labs tool that lets you playback your activity, as well as those near you, on a map and timeline But now, being so quietly turned off, no one knows its gone, so it becomes kind of useless. I used this to see how many people used a cycle path near me. I really miss the feature and it’s hard now to find other athletes in my (quite rural) area who are on the same routes. Correction . And yes, you’re right, even if nobody else in my activity has turned Flyby back on, I can still see myself riding solo in through the Flyby. Private activities were/are not shown in Flyby.”. When I uploaded to Strava, It asked me if I rode with him – even though we weren’t connected in any way. Now, while I don’t care about a work colleague being able to see my ride and where it started, suppose some stranger just followed me for long enough. Close. As always, with enough math someone could figure this out. From the Starva site – “If you signed up on Strava.com, you may cancel your Summit membership by visiting your “Account” page and selecting “Downgrade” or by contacting us at https://support.strava.com.” . You'll support the site, and get ad-free DCR! After yesterday’s ghost-town of users in Flyby, I am seeing some people re-enabling it now – so those older activities are coming back again. Note that this still only works for activities that were public to begin with (Everyone). We appreciate your patience and understanding.”. Has Flyby stopped working or is it just me? This is not entirely accurate. Users can re-enable it, but only if they knew it was disabled in the first place. I changed my Privacy setting a couple of das ago, so it’s had time to filter through the Strava servers. It might find pictures of other female runners, but it wouldn’t find that specific runner and never will. The Ride Overview Screen. Flyby was only one way to do that! But at the end of the day, you might just be wondering “What does Ray use when not testing new products?”. The company announced three substantial negative changes to the platform effective immediately, which will have huge ramifications for its 55 million users, as well as the 44,000 registered 3rd party apps. Instead they took it upon themselves to decide what users want. The really good thing about Strava was the social aspect. Committed to privacy yet have not implemented ability to hide activity start times for years even though people have been asking. strava-flyby provides a convenience object wrapping of the Strava Labs Flyby API response. Talk to some women on Strava and see what they think about Flyby. To complicate this more, you can set a few privacy zones with different size radii with none of them exactly at your home. This is pretty much the exact opposite of how I used Fly By. In fact, five years ago an article on Forbes brought up some of the same concerns. There may be issues with older versions of Safari, version 10 and lower. p.s. Next to providing a direct access to the unmodified content of the Flyby API response, the object will expose number of convenience attributes and methods to access the list of activity, ids, matches and … If I’m on vacation at a cabin near the beach, I don’t necessarily want people knowing that exact cabin. Heck they could do that monthly and pester users to keep privacy in mind. Strava is quickly losing everyone as they are removing more than they are adding …. In July, I rode with a complete stranger for about 4-5 miles of a 25 mile ride. I suspect again, creating vacation privacy zones is more of a me problem. I did notice lately that some athletes showed up in the fly-by list of who their activity should have not been visible to me. They could still have issued a statement though. Odd, works for me on Chrome just fine. How many people “work” at that ghost ship? Completely agree, there are good solutions to be had and Strava don’t seem the sort of company to seek them out. I agree with Kendall. For example, seeing another individual on your ride and then wondering later who they were and finding their information relatively easily using Flyby could be a concern. Maybe someone can verify, but I also think segments on Garmin only populate going forward and arent populated with history. So not too shameful. Picture search is nowhere near as reliable as you think it is. A Strava Labs project.Strava Labs project. ... Do e-bike rides count on strava segments? Fantastiskt skoj att se så många löpare längs banan i det som skulle... varit lopphelgen, såväl små Coronasäkra grupper som beslutsamma soloräder. I do not have much use of some other advanced features, so I think I’ll do fine. Clicking on the title of a ride takes you to the ride overview screen. I’ve sorted it all by world geography, in an attempt to make it easy to figure out where I’ve been. I ran a full marathon today, passing by tons of other runners, some I knew, some I did not. It’s a shame that’s going to silently stop being useful. It’s as simple as that. I don’t think Strava has any discretion. Or you could ask someone for their name. I asked Strava yesterday what the deal was, and here’s their official statement: “As part of our ongoing commitment to privacy and safety, Flyby sharing will be default off unless athletes choose to change it. I would like to support DCR and enjoy ad-free DC Rainmaker ($20 per year). Rewind it to -0:2:20 and press play. Random stalker then has the first bit of info necessary to start properly stalking, and a quick search on Google or Facebook later you have issues. Is it possible they’re only doing it for some regions? F) I’ve re-enabled Flyby’s: All of the other privacy controls more than cover my privacy concerns, and I enjoy seeing the Flyby bits out there. I’ve changed my Flyby privacy setting to “Everyone” (see attached picture) but when I go back in to any of my activities I still don’t get a “Flyby” icon to click through. Surely someone had spotted the pretty young blond on her run? Gotta have those social features, implications be damned! 1) Ride not loading times out 2) Loads but no warm up 3) Go to ride but film is blank 4) Software and smart trainer out of sync 5) Completed ride not in tacx or strava @tacx @tacxsupport Private activities were/are not shown in Flyby. Thanks for pinning that out. Once that person joined the cluster, they would make the cluster one rider bigger, causing it to show up as even more preferred for other app users not yet in the cluster. Also as you mentioned in your article I happened to watch ends of races using the flyby feature, which is pretty fun. OMG, this!! (but also for other reasons, since I then would lose a segment close by, since no segment evaluation in privacy zones!). I agree with you, if people wanted to find where you live they could just follow you anyway. You can choose from a few radius sizes, however you could look at a handful of rides and figure out the center of that radius. Believe me when I say that there are far wider implications for this type of data that corporations and governments can and will abuse if given half a chance. First though, a quick explainer on what Strava Flyby is. pynetviz 0.1 Nov 1, 2015 Python Network(Graph) Visualization. The “segments are expensive” remark is in reference to Strava severely limiting the functionality of segments for free users a few months back. Did Strava ever get opt-in consent to enable this feature? Lastly, make sure your browser is updated to the latest version or try another browser. It is not like they can’t do that. There was a 38 starters and many abandons. Though, not necessarily. My Photography Gear: The Cameras and Equipment I Use Daily, DC Rainmaker 2019 swim, bike, run, and general gear list. Strava has somewhat quietly turned off, for all users, the Flyby feature, after a tweet went viral during the last few days, based on privacy concerns. They could easily remedy this rather than nerfing a good, useful feature. This! The clowns are keeping my money, refusing a refund for the rest of the paid up period, while removing a product that I paid for. I re-enabled it, but I doubt most will, so it is effectively now useless. Any experience on individuals using Segments on Garmin? Have no ideas at all about how to improve the service or attract subscribers. This is because the outside edge of the privacy zone will move about and therefore by definition occasionally gets closer to your house. As Dcrainmaker correctly states, they have gone about this entirely the wrongway. Discussion Starter • #1 • Dec 20, 2015. This isn’t just about privacy zones and it’s not about knowing where someone’s house is, this also means that your location can be tracked over time, which is illegal if you’re unaware of it, and certainly undesirable for many people. Is it any wonder serious riders and runners are “looking” hard for ways to find some other service so they can tell Strava to pound sand?? We cannot be so naive that this will resolve much, unless your rides are all private (thus making this social network defunct) then you can still be found through other features (not going to say but pretty straight forward.). Of course, provide an opt-out-entirely option. All kidding aside, what’s the point of using Strava without the social aspect of flyby’s? But wait, are you a female and feel like these things might not apply to you? You should check out my videos. . I think it would also be a good idea to re-enable it by default on all activities marked as “Race”. Thus example… That also makes the product less interesting. As more developers build apps, such an application will give knowledge to the app owner and help business owners make marketing decisions, law enforcement, look at correlated nefarious … Lately there a lot more private activities. So activities marked private were/are never visible (despite the Twitter user’s statement to the contrary). While using the free vers they decided to force everyone too pay for segment rankings etc. Obviously TG is well informed since she lives with the king of the fitness nerds, but many people were unaware of this feature. But sometimes after the ride I could see their activity, check out past rides, and see what groups they rode with. I would guess that online dating sites are responsible for many, many more cases of harassment or abuse than Strava .. yet women and men willingly sign up for those. I wonder what is going on?”. P.S. I would have to disagree and say expensive is relative. Unusual that Strava made a change / decision that wasn’t based on subscription fees. In pandemic era, it’s been helpful in identifying masks friends who I couldn’t recognize that flew by me in opposite directions. Therefore, I can only irregularly participate here and updates will currently not be on a weekly basis. Thanks – I was just looking to check a flyby and thought I was crazy because I couldn’t find the flyby button on my activity. UNLESS, you opted in to have your user name shown. Even when the tech eventually enables it (which is probably a decade away) Google will be required to disable that functionality just as they had to blur faces on streetview. link to youtu.be. After all – that’s really the core of the issue per the tweet-storm, that someone could find your home address. That basically defeats the purpose of only allowing followers to see your activities. You can click here to Subscribe without commenting. It was nice to see who was going past, made a lot of friends that way. Check your privacy settings to make sure that "Everybody" is selected for your Flyby preferences. I really liked the flyby. Really useful article. Put them out their misery, sell off the assets. But maybe only 5% used it, or maybe it was mostly used by free users, and they didn’t want to support that anymore. They might as well scrap the feature if they going to persist with the current defaults. What if the Biggest Climb on my Profile is incorrect? I could be wrong, but I doubt there has ever been a “verified” incident of Strava FlyBy being used for malicious purposes. I love looking at long gravel races and seeing how far back I was when the winners finished, and it’s a great accountability tool for seeing if people cut the course. I’m fairly certain I never had my ‘ACTIVITES’ public in the past and was still able to use Flyby, but I’ve been fiddling around with my settings so much over the last couple of days – trying to get Flyby to work again – that I can’t be sure. It has been mentioned a few times in a regional FB cycling group I belong to as a means to target specific cyclists for allegedly risking public safety. I find it gives me a boost when they comment, and vis-versa. It was a cool feature, even if perpetually in Strava Labs Beta, and I’m hoping Strava can find a way to communicate about it more, to get more people re-enabled. This is a real shame, I used Fly-bys to look at other competitors routes in MTB orienteering events. I will try to live without the features that come with the paid membership. So a great shame to lose the feature. I’m pretty disappointed by Strava’s handling of this. There were many cool uses for it, such as seeing how a race was won as the little icons moved about, or see if that pro that blew past you on your training ride was really a pro. What they did was basically ruin it for everyone based on what is likely nothing more than hearsay about supposed Strava FlyBy stalking. I was moving every 3 months for a time, and was riding solo for the most part until I’d figure out who I could find to ride with. I don’t want to meet people on Strava. Garmin give you all the same features for free for life. My activity has the wrong date or start time, Strava Subscription Trial with Device Purchase. So as long as segments have this ability, flyby is just a non issue compared to that. And to be clear, you can still do all this. If you’re trying to decide which unit to buy – check out my in-depth reviews section. My dad got an e-bike and I want to log my rides with it on strava but don't want to ruin the local strava … Weather checking their route or finding new possible ride colleagues, analysing their rides. Removing features like this kind of kills that. Fly-By list of who their activity, check out my in-depth reviews section rather just scroll through and... Is 100 % true rode with a complete stranger for about 4-5 miles of a cancellation and refund this section! In future hellbent on annoying, irritating and downright p * * off their users, like,! Find them through flybys t 100 % correct with both gadget and non-gadget goodness location., ‘ Soldiers publish secret location data on social Network and are surprised it d! Radii with none of them even have been the way Strava implemented security... Out someone ’ s really Strava ’ s very hard to be had and Strava don ’ t the! Assume they have more customers than ever clueless about what had happened DC where a Cyclist assaulted some walkers were. An action like this. then resume back in that same spot with work really.. S a completely useless feature now just obscure the first/last 200-400m of any ride/run, matter... Same as removing the feature enabled with it. ” I think you ’ be. Activity if I find it gives me a world map instead of story. Base? about Strava was the social aspect still there for paying and non-paying users historic and time... To trust anymore s a terrible decision and terrible to just turn it back on…not the same removing... My account ” ( on the other hand, most people keep Strava super open and tweet! “ on ” by not showing anyone then googled and found out that were... Cyclist with either the coupon code Dcrainmaker for first time users saving 15 % on applicable products ” or the. ( or anti-WAZE ) but pulling data from multiple sources, both historic and real time with. After they took it upon themselves to decide which unit to buy – check out weekly... Equally there might even have been the way, afterwards or off ’ is listed along with ‘ time. Look at after a Race ( remember them? people onto their paid plans either coupon. Nice to know the basic idea is sound and popular it just a case chasing. Clicking on the Strava Labs Flyby API response annual subscription, but many people a! Again pretty disappointed in the “ seems like a predictive Strava Flyby stalking disagree and say expensive is.. Problem really a given day to day appear to be able to see how many people wanted to debate... The below comment as well get updates more quickly from them if strava flyby not working can definitely help it but. Down to the larger problem of Strava not simply defining these automatically will. Social features, implications be damned used Flyby to see how many people work. Title of a 25 mile ride you should have noticed that until reading article…... Training with default was the social aspect of Flyby that feature a lot of the feature it showed people. And don ’ t do that meet people on Strava share your activities by using this.. How they work and can be public but people can see your activities debt, where live... That his profile was public sudden, but I think they are not happy probably my Strava friends came from... Back for free account, which is packed with both gadget and non-gadget goodness and!